Refinish Bathtub Pros Cons Cost

A Complete Guide for Homeowners in Sherman, TX and the Texoma Area

Updated January 30, 2025 | 6 min read

Have you ever looked at your old, stained, or chipped bathtub and wondered whether it’s worth saving — or if it’s finally time for a replacement?

Bathtub refinishing (also called reglazing or resurfacing) can be an affordable way to bring new life to your bathroom. But like most remodeling decisions, the right choice depends on your tub’s condition, your long-term plans, and your budget.

At MJB Interiors, we’ve guided countless homeowners across Sherman, Denison, and McKinney through this exact decision. In this article, we’ll explain what refinishing really involves, which tubs can be reglazed, how it compares to replacement, and when it makes sense to do one over the other.

By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of whether refinishing will meet your needs — or if replacing your tub is the smarter long-term investment.

What Is Bathtub Refinishing?

Bathtub refinishing is the process of restoring the surface of your existing tub rather than replacing it. The goal is to repair minor imperfections and apply a fresh, durable coating that makes it look brand new again.

The Refinishing Process

Here’s what a professional refinisher typically does:

1. Cleaning and Prep: The surface is deep-cleaned to remove soap scum, mineral deposits, and grime.
2. Repairs: Minor chips, cracks, and scratches are filled and smoothed.
3. Etching: The tub surface is lightly etched or treated with a bonding agent so the new coating adheres properly.
4. Priming and Coating: Several layers of primer and acrylic or epoxy-based coating are sprayed or rolled on for a smooth finish.
5. Curing: The coating cures for 24–48 hours before the tub is ready for use.

When done professionally, a refinished tub can last 7 to 15 years, depending on how often it’s used and how it’s maintained.

Refinishing is a great option if your bathtub is structurally sound but just looks old or worn.

Which Bathtub Materials Can Be Refinished?

Not every tub can be refinished successfully. The material matters a lot when deciding whether reglazing will hold up long-term.

Materials That Can Be Refinished

✔ Porcelain: Excellent candidate for reglazing; results are smooth and long-lasting.
✔ Fiberglass: Can be refinished, though it requires special prep due to its flexibility.
✔ Acrylic: Works well for light cosmetic updates, though not as durable as porcelain or cast iron.
✔ Cast Iron: Ideal for refinishing; the sturdy base allows for strong adhesion and a lasting finish.

Materials That Cannot Be Refinished

❌ Plastic or low-grade acrylic tubs that flex or warp easily.
❌ Tubs with deep structural cracks, rust holes, or soft spots.
❌ Natural materials like stone, copper, or wood — which require custom restoration, not coating.

If your tub falls into the “cannot be refinished” category, replacement will be the better (and often safer) investment.

Pros of Refinishing Your Bathtub

Refinishing offers several advantages — especially if you want a refreshed look without a full renovation.

1. A Cost-Effective Alternative to Replacement

The average cost to refinish a bathtub ranges from $300 to $600, while replacing a tub typically costs $1,500 to $5,000+ after factoring in demolition, plumbing, tile, and installation.
If your tub is structurally sound but looks worn, refinishing can save you thousands of dollars while still giving your bathroom an updated look.

2. Faster and Less Invasive

Replacing a tub can take several days or even a week — especially if tile, drywall, or plumbing need to be redone. Refinishing, on the other hand, can be completed in a single day and ready for use within 48 hours.

3. Eco-Friendly

Instead of sending your old tub to a landfill, refinishing allows you to reuse what you already have. It’s an environmentally friendly option that reduces waste and conserves materials.

4. A Fresh, Like-New Appearance

A refinished tub looks brand new. It covers discoloration, scratches, and surface stains. If your bathtub still functions well but looks tired, reglazing can make it the centerpiece of your bathroom again — without breaking your budget.

Cons of Refinishing Your Bathtub

Of course, refinishing isn’t perfect. There are some trade-offs to consider before deciding.

1. Chemical Fumes During Application

The coatings used in bathtub refinishing release strong fumes during the process. Professional refinishers use respirators, fans, and ventilation systems to manage odors, but homeowners should avoid using the bathroom until it’s fully cured.

2. Shorter Lifespan Than Replacement

While a new bathtub can last 20 years or more, refinishing typically lasts 7–15 years, depending on care and usage. Using abrasive cleaners or dropping heavy objects (like shampoo bottles) can shorten its lifespan.
If the tub is in a guest bathroom with lighter use, refinishing may last much longer.

3. Not Suitable for All Situations

Refinishing won’t fix structural damage, deep cracks, or severe rust. It’s a surface solution — not a rebuild. If your tub flexes, leaks, or feels soft underfoot, refinishing is only a temporary fix.

Refinishing vs. Replacing a Bathtub — Cost and Performance

Here’s a side-by-side look at how the two options compare:

Bathtub Refinishing

• Cost: $300–$600
• Time Required: 4–6 hours
• Durability: 7–15 years
• Eco-Friendly: Yes
• Maintenance: Gentle cleaning; avoid harsh chemicals

Bathtub Replacement

• Cost: $1,500–$5,000+
• Time Required: 2–5 days
• Durability: 20+ years
• Eco-Friendly: No (old tub is discarded)
• Maintenance: Standard upkeep

If your current tub is functional and has only surface wear, refinishing makes financial sense. But if you’re already doing a larger bathroom remodel, replacing the tub often yields a better long-term result.

When Is Refinishing a Good Idea?

Refinishing is best for homeowners who want a cosmetic update without major construction.

Refinishing is ideal if:

• Your tub has cosmetic issues like stains, scratches, or dull color.
• You want a cost-effective update under $1,000.
• You’re not changing the layout of your bathroom.
• The tub is made of porcelain, fiberglass, acrylic, or cast iron.

Replacement is better if:

• Your tub has structural or rust damage.
• You want a new shape, depth, or built-in features.
• You’re already remodeling the rest of the bathroom.
• Your tub is made from a material that cannot be refinished.

For example, if your bathtub is chipped or yellowed but still sturdy, refinishing is a smart short-term fix. But if you’re installing a new tile surround, upgrading fixtures, or converting from a tub to a walk-in shower, replacing the tub will make more sense.

Should You Refinish or Replace Your Bathtub?

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your goals, budget, and timeline.

• If your tub is structurally sound and only has cosmetic wear, refinishing can make it look brand new for a fraction of the cost.
• If your tub is damaged, outdated in style, or part of a larger remodel, replacement will be the better long-term investment.

At MJB Interiors, we help homeowners across Texoma make these decisions every day. Our design-build process allows you to explore all options — from simple refinishing to full bathroom remodels — with clear, upfront pricing and expert guidance.

Ready to Update Your Bathroom?

Whether you decide to refinish your existing tub or replace it during a complete remodel, MJB Interiors can help you design a space that’s both functional and beautiful.

We specialize in bathroom remodeling, kitchen renovations, and whole-home transformations throughout Sherman, Denison, and surrounding areas — always with craftsmanship you can trust and communication you can count on.

Book a Design Consultation →

Or visit our Bathroom Remodeling page to explore ideas, materials, and real project photos from our recent remodels.

Summary: The Bottom Line on Bathtub Refinishing

If your bathtub looks worn but still works fine, refinishing can save thousands while delivering an impressive before-and-after transformation.
However, if you’re dealing with cracks, leaks, or planning a full renovation, replacement is the smarter long-term move.

Either way, improving your bathtub’s appearance is one of the fastest ways to elevate your bathroom’s comfort, cleanliness, and value.